A credit agreement requires “annual reviewed financial statements” and the borrower discovers, three weeks before the deadline, that what their accountant produces is a compilation. The gap between those two words is a different engagement, a different fee, and roughly a month of work.

What are the three levels?

They are distinct services a CPA provides, differing in how much work is performed and what assurance is expressed.

Compilation Review Audit
What the CPA does Presents management’s figures in statement form Analytical procedures and inquiry Testing, confirmation, observation, and evidence
Assurance expressed None Limited (negative) assurance Opinion (reasonable assurance)
Independence required Not always Yes Yes
Relative cost Lowest Middle Highest
Relative time Days to weeks Weeks Weeks to months

The essential difference is verification. A compilation puts management’s numbers into proper format without testing them. A review applies analytical procedures and inquiry, and concludes that the CPA is not aware of material modifications needed. An audit gathers evidence and expresses an opinion.

What does “limited assurance” actually mean?

It means the CPA performed analytical procedures and inquiries, and on that basis is not aware of any material modification that should be made. It is a negatively worded conclusion, and that phrasing is deliberate.

An audit says the statements are presented fairly, in all material respects. A review says nothing came to our attention suggesting they aren’t. Those are meaningfully different statements, and lenders price the difference.

Which level does a lender require?

There is no universal rule, but the pattern is consistent: the requirement escalates with facility size, leverage, and how much the lender is relying on earnings rather than collateral.

Smaller collateral-based facilities frequently accept company-prepared or compiled statements, because the lender is verifying the collateral directly through a field exam rather than relying on the statements. Larger facilities, cash-flow-based structures, and acquisition financings generally move to reviewed or audited statements, because the earnings figure is doing the work.

Ask what your agreement requires and by what date, and confirm your accountant is engaged to deliver that level. This is one of the more common technical defaults, and it is entirely avoidable, as covered in loan covenants explained.

Why does an asset-based lender care less?

Because it is running its own verification. A field exam tests receivables, inventory, and dilution directly, on site, at the borrower’s expense, which substitutes for the assurance an audit would provide. What that exam covers is set out in the ABL field exam.

That is also why an asset-based facility can often be arranged for a company that could not satisfy an audited-statement requirement, which is part of the broader distinction in cash flow lending vs asset-based lending.

Does an audit replace a quality of earnings analysis?

No, and conflating the two costs sellers real money in transactions. An audit asks whether the statements are fairly presented under the applicable framework. A quality of earnings analysis asks whether the earnings are sustainable, recurring, and attributable to the business a buyer is acquiring.

An audited company can still have a poor quality of earnings, and frequently does. The distinction is developed in quality of earnings, and the related question of which adjustments hold up is in addbacks that survive diligence.

What about interim statements?

Most credit agreements require monthly or quarterly internally prepared statements alongside the annual CPA-prepared set, usually within 30 or 45 days of period end, often with a compliance certificate.

Those interim deadlines cause more defaults than the annual requirement does, because they recur twelve times a year and depend on a close process that has to work every month. A business that cannot close in 30 days should negotiate the deadline at term sheet stage rather than miss it repeatedly.

When should a company step up a level voluntarily?

Three situations make it worth doing before anyone requires it.

Preparing for a sale or a raise in the next 18 to 24 months, since buyers and their lenders will want a track record rather than a single year. Approaching a facility size where the requirement is coming anyway, because the first year of a higher engagement level is the slow one. And when the internal accounting function has outgrown its controls, where the engagement pays for itself in what it finds.

The short version

Compilation, review, and audit are three different services with three levels of verification behind them, and the level your credit agreement requires is a covenant like any other. Confirm which one you owe and by when, and remember that an audit answers a narrower question than most owners think it does.

General information, not accounting advice. Engagement standards and requirements should be confirmed with your CPA.